|
While Palestinian terrorism rages on, a new Arab “White Rose” – much
like the World War II German student Nazi
resistance of that name – has been sprouting. Not many Israelis
have acknowledged its existence. But it is high time we did our bit
to help this brave flower blossom.
In my eighteen years living in Israel, two encounters
with Arabs left me with indelible impressions.
The first was a decade ago when my developmentally
delayed daughter, a year old, was hospitalized. She had pneumonia
and uncontrollable seizures and I was simply overwhelmed. Nurses
would pop in to administer drugs and then vanish into thin air. The
remainder of the care was up to us parents.
Souaid, a university-educated Israeli Arab whose
mildly epileptic baby shared the room, took me under her wing.
Behind the scenes, she urged the nurses to help me out. She was
direct and commanded their respect. And they obliged her. Souaid was
a kind friend to me throughout her baby’s hospitalization.
On Friday evening, she and her baby disappeared from
our room after candle-lighting. I searched the ward to no avail.
Several hours later, they reappeared. Souaid explained that they’d
gone to an empty room in deference to the Shabbat atmosphere and the
religious fathers who were visiting with their children. By the time
her baby was released, Souaid had shared many long, intimate chats
with me as well as with Chavi, an ultra-orthodox woman in our room.
After they had bid one another farewell, Souaid took me aside and
said: “I can’t believe it; Chavi told me I am a righteous gentile.”
“Chavi was right,” I told her.
Six years later, two other Arabs impacted on my life.
On a hot August afternoon in 2001, Izzadin
Al Masri brutally murdered my
fifteen year old daughter, Malki,
along with fourteen other innocent Jews. Eight children and one
entire family were among the dead.
Ahlam Tamimi, a Palestinian journalist, disguised
herself as a secular Jewish tourist and escorted Al Masri through
central Jerusalem while chatting in fluent English to dispel the
suspicions of a police force on high alert.
From an Israeli prison cell where she is now serving
16 life terms, Tamimi
spoke a day before last week’s Israeli elections. “I am not
sorry for what I did,” she declared. “I will get out of prison and I
refuse to recognize Israel’s existence,” she added. “Discussions
will only take place after Israel recognizes that this is Islamic
land,” she predicted.
Several years ago Tamimi spoke with Barbara Victor,
author of “Shahidas: The Female Kamikazie of Palestine” In her book,
Victor writes that Tamimi who “didn’t regret the deaths of all these
children added ‘They should have returned to Poland, Russia or the
United States, to the countries their parents came from.’”
In ending Malki’s beautiful life, Al Masri and Tamimi
condemned me to never-ending pain and longing. So I think I would be
forgiven for keeping my distance from Arabs as long as I live.
But the fact is I would never consider doing that.
Today I hear many compelling Arab voices rising above the
fundamentalist Islamic din. More and more courageous Arabs, both
Muslim and Christian, are outspoken defenders of the United States,
Israel and the Jews. After a steady diet of Muslim bloodshed, their
messages have been pure ambrosia.
The latest one of these “Souaids” – righteous
gentiles all – to step into the spotlight is psychiatrist, Dr. Wafa
Sultan (at left). Her February
debut on
Al Jazeera has attracted over one million listeners on the
internet. Sultan doesn’t mince words. Pitted for the Al Jazeera
interview against an Algerian cleric and an Egyptian professor of
religious studies, she opened on the offensive: “The clash we are
witnessing around the world is not a clash of religions, or a clash
of civilizations. .. It is a clash between civilization and
backwardness… between barbarity and rationality, between freedom
and oppression… Civilizations do not clash, but compete.”
Dr. Sultan was born and raised in a traditional
Muslim home in Syria. From grade-school on she was indoctrinated, by
her own account, to hate Jews and Israel. After witnessing the
brutal murder of her respected medical school professor by two
Muslim Brotherhood terrorists, she abandoned her religious beliefs.
Soon afterwards, she immigrated to the United States with her
husband and children. There, studying in a California hospital, she
met Jews for the first time. Before long she embarked on her fight
against the anti-Semitism endemic in Muslim society.
Sultan incensed her Al Jazeera opponents with a
striking observation: “The Jews have come from the tragedy and
forced the world to respect them, with their knowledge, not with
their terror; with their work, not with their crying and yelling.”
Dr. Sultan joins the ranks of other Arab heroines
like Noni Darwish (pictured left), a Palestinian who moved to the United States
after completing her university studies.
Ms Darwish relates memories of her pre-school
education: “A Jewish person was portrayed like less than human, a
dog, an evil alien from outer space…cursed by G-d and the main
mission of Islam was to get rid of Jews.”
Her father, a prominent military officer mobilized
Palestinian forces into Israeli territory and was killed by the
Israelis in retaliation. Nevertheless Darwish says, “I blame the
Middle Eastern Islamic culture and the propaganda of hatred taught
to children from birth.” for his death.
Brigitte Gabriel
(at left), a Christian Lebanese, was ten years
old when her home was bombed by Muslims. By the age of twenty, she
says, most of her friends had died at the hands of Islamic
terrorists. Her first personal encounter with Jews and their
compassion was when she rushed her seriously injured mother over the
border into Israel for life-saving medical treatment.
She says she was “amazed when I saw Americans waking
up on September 12, 2001, and asking themselves “Why do they hate
us?”…they hate us because we are defined in their eyes by one simple
word: “infidels” Under the banner of Islam…they murdered Jewish
children in Israel, massacred Christians in Lebanon, killed Copts in
Egypt, Assyrians in Syria, Hindus in India, and expelled almost
900,000 Jews from Muslim lands. We Middle Eastern infidels paid the
price then. Now infidels worldwide are paying the price for
indifference and shortsightedness.”
Gabriel defends Israel and warns of the dangers of
“Islamic totalitarianism” by lecturing on American college campuses
and through her organization, American Congress for Truth.
Last month the New York Times published an op-ed by a
Muslim academic at Yale University,
Irshad Manji. Entitled: “How I
Learned to Love the Wall” [PDF], it defends the barrier’s construction in
much the same way as the Israeli government does. “Since the barrier
went up”, writes Manji, “suicide attacks have plunged, which means
innocent Arab lives have been spared along with Jewish ones. Does a
concrete effort to save civilian lives justify the hardship posed by
this structure? The humanitarian in me bristles, but ultimately
answers yes.”
Ms. Manji is the best-selling author of “The Trouble
with Islam Today: A Muslim’s Call for Reform in Her Faith” published
in 2004. There, on her web-site and in international TV and radio
interviews Manji crusades for the emergence of moderate Islam to
counter terrorist Islam. She asserts that mainstream Muslims, those
who do not actually engage in terrorism, are in denial about the
role their religion plays in encouraging the bloodshed. She
challenges those who “assure us that Islam is an innocent bystander
in today’s terrorism” and points to the video legacies of the
terrorists themselves – replete with Koranic quotes – as proof in
point.
These Christian and Muslim Arabs are more courageous
and honest than many of my compatriots. Israeli reserves of these
traits are sorely depleted. Too many of us have been, to borrow an
image brought by Manji describe her own people, “sticking fingers in
our ears and chanting ‘Islam means peace’”.
And if one can judge from our newly elected Prime
Minister, then even Israel’s leaders lack the mettle and morals of
our tenacious foreign allies. Imagine how uplifted our enemies must
have been by Ehud Olmert words several months ago. In an
alarming speech to the Israel Policy Forum he conceded: “We are
tired of fighting, we are tired of being courageous, we are tired of
winning, we are tired of defeating our enemies.”
He is not far behind another veteran Israeli
politician, Shulamit Aloni (see left), who announced in a pre-election
interview on national radio “My shame over being an Israeli grows
constantly.” And a Haaretz columnist, Benny Tzifir, in critiquing
the chase, capture and arrest of a Palestinian carrying an explosive
belt wrote “We are the ones losing our humanity”.
We need to extend a supportive hand to these
inspirational Arab activists who, unlike Olmert and his cohorts, are
wide awake, energetic and proud of Israel. We owe it both to
ourselves and to them. Every one of them lives in the shadows of
phone and e-mail death threats or “fatwas” from the Muslims they
challenge. A New York Times article carelessly revealed the location
of Dr. Sultan’s residence. Consequently, her supporters have been
canvassing private security firms to donate equipment and services
for her protection. This is where we Jews could make a concrete
donation. We can also support them by arranging radio and TV
appearances and live speaking engagements.
Representatives of Palestinian terror organizations
are routinely hosted on radio and TV. But during the visit to the
region that inspired her New York Times op-ed about the security
fence, Manji was not interviewed even once by Israeli journalists.
Is there no spare air-time for Arabs who are not intent on murdering
us?
The three leaders of the German White Rose, a brother
and sister and friend, were arrested, tried and summarily beheaded
by the Nazis in
1943. Their supporters were all subsequently caught
and either executed or sent to concentration camps. Their movement’s
year-long struggle against barbarism (1942-43) never progressed
beyond the hand-printing and distribution of anti-Nazi leaflets.
We must not allow the latter-day “White Rose” to
suffer the same fate.
|